Self-Reliance in SHGs and the Role of NGO Withdrawal

When an NGO helps form a Self-Help Group (SHG), the goal was never to stay forever. From the very beginning, the exit is built into the plan. The real measure of success is not how well an SHG performs while the NGO is present – it is whether the group can stand on its own once the NGO steps back. This gradual handover of responsibility, from external agency to the group itself, is what the process of self-reliance and NGO withdrawal is all about. It is one of the most critical, and often most delicate, phases in the lifecycle of any SHG.

Why self-reliance is the end goal of SHG formation 🔗

Self-Help Groups are designed from the ground up around the principle of mutual aid and collective self-governance. Members pool savings, make internal loans, and resolve disputes among themselves. The democratic, peer-controlled structure is intentional – it builds ownership. But in the early stages, most SHGs need an outside hand. NGOs play a foundational role in mobilizing members, providing training, facilitating bank linkages, and building the group’s internal capacity. The trouble begins when this support becomes a permanent crutch.

Research consistently shows that many SHGs are heavily dependent on their promoter NGOs and government agencies, and the withdrawal of that support often leads to group collapse. This is a significant structural vulnerability. It means that if the process of building independence is not consciously embedded into the NGO’s engagement strategy from day one, the SHG may never actually become self-reliant. The group learns to wait for instructions rather than to lead.

True self-reliance means the group can conduct regular meetings, maintain accounts, resolve conflicts, access credit, and pursue economic activities – all without the NGO’s involvement. Reaching this point is not accidental. It requires a structured, phased withdrawal strategy from the supporting organization.

The transition to independence: how NGO withdrawal works in practice 🔗

NGO withdrawal is not a sudden exit. It is a gradual, phased process that mirrors how the SHG itself develops. In the early formation stage, the NGO’s presence is intensive – facilitating meetings, training members in savings and bookkeeping, and establishing group norms. As the group matures and demonstrates that it can handle its own affairs, the NGO reduces its visit frequency, stops attending every meeting, and eventually transitions to a monitoring role rather than an operational one.

This phased approach is deliberate. SHG-promoting institutions (SHGPIs) – which include NGOs – play a significant role in organizing women into SHGs, linking them to formal banks, and building the capacity of group members and other stakeholders. The quality of this nurturing process directly determines whether the group can sustain itself after the NGO leaves. Groups that receive rushed or target-driven support often struggle. When NGOs focus on forming as many groups as possible rather than investing in quality, the groups they leave behind are fragile.

Benchmarks of readiness for NGO withdrawal 🔗

Before stepping back, responsible NGOs typically assess whether certain conditions are in place. These readiness indicators include consistent attendance at group meetings, regular savings contributions without reminders, functional and accurate bookkeeping maintained by group members, transparent internal lending with documented repayments, and the ability to independently liaise with banks or government programs. Capacity-building programs covering financial literacy, entrepreneurship, and group management are frequently conducted for SHG members as part of this preparation. The goal is not just that the group functions – it is that the group functions without being told to.

When these markers are consistently present, the NGO can confidently begin reducing its involvement. The transition is considered complete when the SHG can independently access resources, resolve internal disputes, and maintain its financial activities without external prompting.

What makes withdrawal go wrong 🔗

NGO withdrawal fails most often when it happens too soon or too abruptly. The lack of professionalism within some SHGs – which can lead to accounting errors and financial mismanagement – is a real barrier to sustainable independence. If the group hasn’t developed internal leadership strong enough to hold things together without an external authority figure, the departure of the NGO creates a vacuum. Attendance drops. Savings become irregular. Disputes go unresolved. In some cases, groups dissolve entirely.

The challenge is compounded by external pressures. Patriarchal social norms, lack of rural banking access, and limited market connectivity can all undermine a group’s independence even when its internal functioning is strong. This is why the process of building self-reliance cannot be viewed in isolation – it has to be paired with structural support at the community and institutional level.

Cross-learning and cluster building: groups teaching each other 🔗

One of the most effective tools for sustaining SHG independence after NGO withdrawal is the formation of clusters – networks of multiple SHGs from the same geographic area that come together for mutual support. Where the NGO once provided guidance, the cluster provides it instead. Groups that have solved a particular problem share the solution with newer or struggling groups. Leadership skills, accounting methods, and market strategies circulate horizontally, from group to group, rather than flowing down from an external organization.

Cluster-level associations are formed to facilitate cooperation, knowledge sharing, and joint initiatives among SHGs in a particular locality. They provide a forum for SHGs to collectively address common challenges, share best practices, and advocate for their interests at the cluster level. This kind of structured peer exchange is powerful precisely because it is internally driven. The knowledge comes from within the community, which makes it more relevant and more trusted.

How clusters strengthen community capacity 🔗

SHG federations were first promoted by NGOs and state governments in the 1990s and were specifically designed to overcome the limitations of individual SHGs and facilitate the withdrawal of promoting institutions, making groups more self-dependent. These federations begin as clusters of 10-20 SHGs, which are then linked to form larger representative bodies. The federation structure gives individual SHGs access to larger capital pools, marketing networks, and policy advocacy platforms that no single group could access on its own.

The cross-learning that happens within clusters also builds the kind of social capital that makes groups resilient. When women from different SHGs meet regularly, they build relationships of trust that extend beyond their immediate group. They begin to see themselves as part of a larger movement rather than an isolated set of members. This shared identity reinforces commitment and accountability. Research on SHGs as platforms for development shows that social capital – defined as norms of trust and reciprocity – is a central factor in enabling groups to function effectively, particularly when external institutional support is reduced.

The role of experienced SHGs in mentoring newer ones 🔗

Within a cluster, older and more experienced SHGs naturally take on a mentoring function. Their members have navigated the early challenges of group formation, managed their first loans, negotiated with banks, and possibly launched small enterprises. This lived experience is an asset. Newer groups benefit enormously from direct, peer-to-peer guidance that is grounded in the same socio-economic reality they face. This model of horizontal knowledge transfer also reduces the dependency on NGO expertise, which is the entire point of the withdrawal process.

The Government of India has formally recognized the value of this structure. Through the Deen Dayal Antyodaya Yojana – National Rural Livelihoods Mission (DAY-NRLM), the government actively promotes SHG federations such as Village Organizations and Cluster Level Federations to provide handholding support to individual groups – precisely filling the support role that NGOs once held.

Focus on economic activities: the foundation of lasting independence 🔗

Self-reliance is not just about running meetings without an NGO in the room. The deepest form of independence is economic. An SHG that generates income – through collective enterprises, member businesses, or market-linked activities – has both the financial resources and the internal motivation to sustain itself long-term. This is why a focus on income-generating activities is not just one component of SHG functioning; it is the backbone of the entire self-reliance model.

The SHG-Bank Linkage Programme initiated by NABARD in 1992 has played a key role in enabling SHGs to access collateral-free bank loans, strengthening financial inclusion and self-reliance at the grassroots level. By giving groups access to formal credit, this program removes one of the core dependencies that made groups reliant on NGO-mediated funding. As of June 2025, over 10 crore women are part of 91 lakh SHGs across India, and the Economic Survey 2022-23 reported a loan repayment rate of over 96%, reflecting the financial discipline and credit reliability that economically active SHGs develop over time.

Types of income-generating activities SHGs pursue 🔗

The range of economic activities SHGs engage in is broad, and it reflects the resources and skills available within specific communities. Common activities include tailoring and textile production, food processing and catering, handicrafts and artisanal goods, agricultural input supply and collective farming, and small-scale retail. SHGs encourage members to undertake small-scale entrepreneurial ventures by providing loans, training, and guidance, which not only boosts local economies but also builds self-reliance among rural communities.

What distinguishes a thriving economic SHG from a dormant one is not just the activity itself – it is the market linkage. A group that produces handicrafts but has no channel to sell them will plateau quickly. This is where clusters and federations again play a critical role. Governments and NGOs should help SHGs connect with larger markets for their products, and ideally, the federation structure eventually enables groups to negotiate directly with buyers, distributors, and government procurement channels without intermediaries.

Sustainable income generation vs. short-term activity 🔗

Not every economic activity an SHG undertakes is sustainable. Some groups pursue activities that are viable only while subsidized by a government scheme or NGO grant. When the funding ends, the activity ends. The goal of genuine self-reliance is to identify and invest in activities that generate recurring revenue on their own market merit – products and services for which real demand exists independently of donor support.

This requires a shift in how SHGs are guided during the economic planning phase. Rather than being assigned a project by an NGO, a truly self-reliant SHG does its own needs assessment, identifies local market demand, allocates its internal funds, and evaluates results. The NGO’s role in this stage is to build the analytical and entrepreneurial capacity for this kind of decision-making – not to make the decisions. Capacity-building and skill development training programs are frequently conducted for SHG members to enhance financial literacy, vocational skills, and managerial capabilities precisely for this reason.

The bigger picture: why self-reliance matters for women’s empowerment 🔗

The process of SHG self-reliance is inseparable from the broader project of women’s empowerment. When a group of women can manage their own finances, run their own enterprises, resolve their own disputes, and advocate for their own interests without needing an NGO to hold their hand – something fundamental has shifted. The primary purpose of SHGs has been to economically empower women and communities through saving, lending, and bank-linkage programs that provide access to larger pools of capital. But the empowerment goes deeper than economics.

Independence builds confidence. Women who lead self-sustaining groups develop leadership skills, decision-making ability, and a sense of agency that extends well beyond their SHG activities. Many become local leaders, Gram Panchayat representatives, and community advocates. The self-reliance of the group becomes the self-reliance of its members – and that is the transformation the entire model was designed to produce.

NGO withdrawal, when done well, is not abandonment. It is recognition. It says: you are ready to lead yourselves. The clusters and federations that fill the space left by the NGO are not replacements – they are the community’s own infrastructure of support, built from within. And the economic activities that sustain the group are not handouts – they are the fruit of collective discipline, skill, and determination.

What do you think? If an SHG’s long-term success depends on the quality of the NGO’s exit strategy, what responsibilities should NGOs build into their engagement from the very start of group formation? And in communities where patriarchal norms actively limit women’s economic participation, can SHG self-reliance ever be truly complete without broader social change?

References

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-help_group_(finance)
2. https://www.drishtiias.com/to-the-points/Paper2/self-help-groups-shgs
3. https://academic.oup.com/cdj/article/58/2/283/6374653
4. https://vajiramandravi.com/current-affairs/self-help-groups/
5. https://weema.org/shg-page
6. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8350316/
7. https://www.iasexpress.net/ie-pedia/the-emergence-of-self-help-groups-shgs-in-contemporary-times-points-to-the-slow-but-steady-withdrawal-of-the-state-from-developmental-activities-examine-the-role-of-the-shgs/
8. https://www.indiafarm.org/gov-of-india/schemes/self-help-groups-shgs-india/
9. https://www.drishtiias.com/daily-updates/daily-news-analysis/shgs-in-india
10. https://www.nextias.com/blog/self-help-groups-shgs/